Which magnesium to choose for fatigue and muscle cramps?
Citrate, bisglycinate, oxide, marine: how to choose a well-absorbed magnesium, how much to take, what it can do for cramps and when to see a doctor.

In short
To decide which magnesium to choose, go for a well-absorbed, well-tolerated form such as magnesium citrate or bisglycinate rather than oxide, which is less well absorbed and more laxative.
- An adult needs around 300 to 350 mg a day, largely covered by diet: a supplement is only useful if your intake is insufficient.
“I’m tired, I get cramps at night, I need magnesium.” This is one of the most frequent requests at the counter of the Pharmacie de Cologny, especially in November, when the days get shorter and fatigue sets in. The magnesium shelf, meanwhile, can be bewildering: tablets, sachets, capsules, ampoules, “marine” or “liposomal” forms…
Before choosing a form, it is worth asking whether magnesium really is the right answer. Here is how we approach it.
What does magnesium do?
Magnesium is involved in several hundred reactions in the body: energy production in cells, muscle contraction and relaxation, nerve transmission, bone strength. It helps reduce fatigue when intake is insufficient.
The reference values used in Switzerland put adult needs at around 300 mg a day for women and 350 mg for men. A varied diet largely covers them: nuts (almonds, cashews), seeds, wholegrains, pulses, green vegetables, cocoa, as well as certain mineral waters rich in magnesium.
Who is short of magnesium?
A genuine deficiency is uncommon in a healthy person who eats a varied diet. However, intake may be insufficient or losses increased in certain situations:
- a diet high in refined products and low in wholegrains, vegetables and pulses;
- intense exercise and heavy sweating;
- prolonged stress, heavy alcohol consumption;
- pregnancy;
- chronic digestive disorders (diarrhoea, inflammatory bowel disease);
- certain medicines taken long term: diuretics, proton pump inhibitors (for stomach acid), certain cancer treatments.
The signs often mentioned (fatigue, cramps, a twitching eyelid, irritability) are not very specific: they can have many other causes, such as a lack of iron, vitamin D or sleep, or a thyroid disorder.
Which magnesium to choose: the different forms
| Form | Absorption | Digestive tolerance | Our view |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magnesium citrate | Good | Fair; possible laxative effect at high doses | A good all-round choice, often as a powder or in sachets |
| Bisglycinate (glycinate) | Good | Very good | Ideal for sensitive bowels |
| Lactate, pidolate, aspartate | Fair to good | Good | Common alternatives at the pharmacy |
| Magnesium chloride | Fair | Marked laxative effect, bitter taste | Not very pleasant for daily use |
| Oxide, “marine” magnesium | Low | Laxative effect common | Lots of magnesium per tablet, but poorly absorbed |
| L-threonate | Good | Good | A recent form, promoted for the brain; data still limited |
Read the label.
“500 mg of magnesium citrate” is not the same as “500 mg of magnesium”. Check the elemental magnesium content per daily dose. In Switzerland, from 250 mg a day, supplements must mention a possible laxative effect.
Combinations with vitamin B6 or taurine are common and may improve tolerance or the benefit of the course, without being essential.
Magnesium and cramps: should you expect much?
This is the big disappointment of the pharmacy shelves. In adults and older people without a deficiency, studies have not shown that magnesium noticeably prevents night-time leg cramps. In pregnant women, the results are contradictory.
A trial of a few weeks may be worth discussing, particularly for athletes who sweat a lot or if your diet is low in magnesium. But other measures are often more effective:
- stretch your calves for a few minutes before bed;
- drink enough, especially after exercise;
- during a cramp, gently stretch the muscle by pulling your toes towards you;
- review your medicines: some can encourage cramps.
How should you take magnesium?
- Split the dose into two or three doses with meals: absorption is better, and so is digestive tolerance.
- Follow a limited course, for example one month, then take stock. If nothing changes, there is no point continuing.
- Stick to the stated dose and do not combine several products that contain it (multivitamins, sports drinks, sachets).
- Space out certain medicines. Magnesium reduces the absorption of several treatments: certain antibiotics (tetracyclines, quinolones), bisphosphonates for osteoporosis, levothyroxine, iron. Leave a gap of a few hours, as advised by your pharmacist.
When should you see a doctor?
Emergency
Watch out for these situations.
If you have kidney failure, do not take magnesium without medical advice, as it may build up in the body. Persistent calf pain, with swelling, heat or redness in one leg only, is not a cramp: seek urgent medical attention to rule out a blood clot (phlebitis). Also see a doctor if you have frequent cramps with muscle weakness, muscle pain while on cholesterol treatment, or fatigue that lasts more than a few weeks.
Persistent fatigue deserves a medical check-up: a blood test can look for a lack of iron, a thyroid disorder or other causes, rather than piling up supplements.
Our advice at the Pharmacie de Cologny
Before suggesting a magnesium, we ask you a few questions: diet, activity, sleep, treatments, how long you have been tired. Often, the answer involves several adjustments rather than a single product. For a more comprehensive approach, our micronutrition service lets us assess your intake and build a suitable programme. If fatigue sets in with winter, our article on vitamin D in winter usefully completes this review.
Browse our selection of food supplements, including a magnesium in L-threonate form:
Frequently asked questions
What is the best form of magnesium?
There is no ideal form for everyone. Citrate and bisglycinate are well absorbed; bisglycinate is the best tolerated by sensitive bowels. Magnesium oxide, which is very widespread, is less well absorbed and more often laxative.
When should I take magnesium, morning or evening?
The time of day matters little; regularity and taking it with meals count for more. Splitting the dose into two, for example at breakfast and dinner, improves tolerance.
How long should I take magnesium for?
A course of about a month lets you judge the effect. If there is no improvement, there is no point continuing, and it is better to look for another cause of the fatigue or cramps with a health professional.
Does magnesium have side effects?
The most common is a laxative effect (loose stools, diarrhoea), especially with oxide and chloride or at high doses. In people with kidney failure, magnesium can build up: it should then only be taken on medical advice.
Can I take magnesium during pregnancy?
Needs increase during pregnancy and magnesium is sometimes suggested for cramps, with variable results. Always ask your doctor, midwife or pharmacist before starting.
Micronutrition & supplements
Further reading
Vitamin D in winter in Switzerland: should you take a supplement?
Around 60% of people in Switzerland lack vitamin D in winter. Recommended daily doses, which form to choose, safety limits and our pharmacists’ advice.
Boosting your immunity before winter: what really works
Sleep, diet, vitamin D, zinc, probiotics: a pharmacist’s guide to what genuinely helps your immunity in winter and which supplements are overrated.



